"The question isn't who is going to let me,it's who is going to stop me."

Wednesday, January 03, 2007

Nathu Ram Godse's Speech At The Trial

" On January 13, 1948, I learnt that Gandhiji had decided to go on fast unto death. The reason given was that he wanted an assurance of Hindu-Muslim Unity... But I and many others could easily see that the real motive... [was] to compel the Dominion Government to pay the sum of Rs 55 crores to Pakistan, the payment of which was emphatically refused by the Government.... But this decision of the people's Government was reversed to suit the tune of Gandhiji's fast. It was evident to my mind that the force of public opinion was nothing but a trifle when compared with the leanings of Gandhiji favourable to Pakistan.

....In 1946 or thereabout, Muslim atrocities perpetrated on Hindus under the Government patronage of Surhawardy in Noakhali made our blood boil. Our shame and indignation knew no bounds when we saw that Gandhiji had come forward to shield that very Surhawardy and began to style him as 'Shaheed Saheb' - a martyr - even in his prayer meetings...

....Gandhiji's influence in the Congress first increased and then became supreme. His activities for public awakening were phenomenal in their intensity and were reinforced by the slogans of truth and non-violence which he ostentatiously paraded before the country... I could never conceive that an armed resistance to the aggressor is unjust... Ram killed Ravan in a tumultuous fight... Krishna killed Kansa to end his wickedness... In condemning Shivaji, Rana Pratap and Guru Govind as 'misguided patriots,' Gandhiji has merely exposed his self-conceit... Gandhiji was, paradoxically, a violent pacifist who brought untold calamities on the country in the name of truth and nonviolence, while Rana Pratap, Shivaji and the Guru will remain enshrined in the hearts of their countrymen forever...

....By 1919, Gandhiji had become desperate in his endeavours to get the Muslims to trust him and went from one absurd promise to another... He backed the Khilafat movement in this country and was able to enlist the full support of the National Congress in that policy... very soon the Moplah Rebellion showed that the Muslims had not the slightest idea of national unity... There followed a huge slaughter of Hindus... The British Government, entirely unmoved by the rebellion, suppressed it in a few months and left to Gandhiji the joy of his Hindu-Muslim Unity... British Imperialism emerged stronger, the Muslims became more fanatical, and the consequences were visited on the Hindus...

The accumulating provocation of 32 years, culminating in his last pro-Muslim fast, at last goaded me to the conclusion that the existence of Gandhiji should be brought to an end immediately... he developed a subjective mentality under which he alone was the final judge of what was right or wrong... Either Congress had to surrender its will to him and play second fiddle to all his eccentricity, whimsicality... or it had to carry on without him... He was the master brain guiding the civil disobedience movement... The movement may succeed or fail; it may bring untold disasters and political reverses, but that could make no difference to the Mahatma's infallibility... These childish inanities and obstinacies, coupled with a most severe austerity of life, ceaseless work and lofty character, made Gandhiji formidable and irresistible... In a position of such absolute irresponsibility, Gandhiji was guilty of blunder after blunder...

....The Mahatma even supported the separation of Sindh from the Bombay Presidency and threw the Hindus of Sindh to the communal wolves. Numerous riots took place in Karachi, Sukkur, Shikarpur and other places in which the Hindus were the only sufferers...

....From August 1946 onwards, the private armies of the Muslim League began a massacre of the Hindus... Hindu blood began to flow from Bengal to Karachi with mild reactions in the Deccan... The Interim government formed in September was sabotaged by its Muslim League members, but the more they became disloyal and treasonable to the government of which they were a part, the greater was Gandhi's infatuation for them...

....The Congress, which had boasted of its nationalism and socialism, secretly accepted Pakistan and abjectly surrendered to Jinnah. India was vivisected and one-third of the Indian territory became foreign land to us... This is what Gandhiji had achieved after 30 years of undisputed dictatorship, and this is what Congress party calls 'freedom'...

....One of the conditions imposed by Gandhiji for his breaking of the fast unto death related to the mosques in Delhi occupied by Hindu refugees. But when Hindus in Pakistan were subjected to violent attacks he did not so much as utter a single word to protest and censure the Pakistan government...

Gandhi is being referred to as the Father of the Nation. But if that is so, he had failed his paternal duty inasmuch as he has acted very treacherously to the nation by his consenting to the partitioning of it... The people of this country were eager and vehement in their opposition to Pakistan. But Gandhiji played false with the people...

....I shall be totally ruined, and the only thing I could expect from the people would be nothing but hatred... if I were to kill Gandhiji. But at the same time, I felt that Indian politics in the absence of Gandhiji would surely be proved practical, able to retaliate, and be powerful with armed forces. No doubt, my own future would be totally ruined, but the nation would be saved from the inroads of Pakistan...

....I do say that my shots were fired at the person whose policy and action had brought rack and ruin and destruction to millions of Hindus... There was no legal machinery by which such an offender could be brought to book, and for this reason I fired those fatal shots...

....I do not desire any mercy to be shown to me... I did fire shots at Gandhiji in open daylight. I did not make any attempt to run away; in fact I never entertained any idea of running away. I did not try to shoot myself... for, it was my ardent desire to give vent to my thoughts in an open Court. My confidence about the moral side of my action has not been shaken even by the criticism levelled of against it on all sides. I have no doubt, honest writers of history will weigh my act and find the true value thereof some day in future. "

19 comments:

Anonymous said...

M.K Gandhi deserved it. People might disagree what go through text and original archives and you would how wrong gandhi was, may it be making Nehru the P.M and not Patel.

May it be fasting just to get his demands dealt with.Partition happened because of Gandhi not because of Jinnah.

Kashmir today is also an issue because of Nehru going to the UN for help when it was an internal matter and could be dealt with and who always backed Nehru GANDHI...

I want to conclude by saying that M.K Gandhi the man the institution was a great man no doubt but he was a single hand in breaking the country.

He had the biggest support group[ which was the Mass Support , he could have done wonders for India if wanted to but dint because of this Narrow thinking.

Anonymous said...

Excellent speech. Its a shame that we are made to believe that Nathuram Godse was deranged. This speech must be a part of the history syllabus in our country. Jai Hind.

Anonymous said...

GODSE'S SPEECH WAS AHEAD OF ITS TIME.ILLETERATE JANTA OF INDIA(BHARAT)ALWAYS LOOKED FOR A "CHARISMA"AND WITH SUBHASH GONE,WHO WERE LEFT..GANDHI&NEHRU,SINCE PATEL BACKED OUT FROM THIS HYPOCRISY AND DIED OF HEART ATTACK UNDER PRESSURE,BUT AT LEAST SAVED HYDERABAD AS HIS PARTING GESTURE!Please watch the film clips of oath taking ceremony(August16,1947)of Nehru as Prime Minister of Free India with Lord and Lady Mountbatten still standing as rulers with the golden thrown behind them and Nehru's voice saying " ALEGIANCE TO CROWN..." in his speech.Is Freedom TAKEN from or GIVEN away?Idiotic sentiment among the foolish-illeterate Indian masses(janta)further promoted by Bollywood films that "Hamne Ang-rezon ko bhaga diya" is a very retarded concept.If anybody deserves to be thanked,then it would be Adolph Hitler,who broke the spine of British Empire by ravaging WWII across the Europe.England won the war with American help but was left economically and militarily broken.They could not sustain their own nation past 1945,let alone running an Empire.They had to leave India,Africa and Far East because sustaining a machinery like British Raj became a thing of the past....

Unknown said...

it is not the issue that whether naturam was right or wrong for assissinated gandhiji,but the issue is what was the feeling behind in the mind of godse.both gandhi and godse were real and true patroits and sons of motherland,both lived and died because of their love towards motherland but the difference is of their thinking.we should not call him a villan.because he had great love and respect for her motherland .he was really a mrytr..i salute him for his patroitism

lageyrahotrehan said...

Brilliantly written speech! But I suspect the writer is having a good laugh somewhere. Nathuram Godse went to school in Baramati up to what was called at that time the Fifth Standard after which he moved to Pune to live with an aunt so to go to school there. Godse dropped out of High School so it is highly debatable whether this speech (which contains much of today's language) is really his. I would really like to know this source by the person who first posted it. It is extremely well written but before we pass judgement on the speech itself, it would be good to verify the source. If the proceedings were 'in camera', who and how did he get it?

Unknown said...

no matter what, there was no reason to kill someone no matter how great the mistake or wrong calculations he made. only GOD is allowed such an action. however, the reason behind the killing is true and it is a pity that he is counted so great when there were millions, if not billions of unknown faces who brought about the freedom of our motherland. sigh.

Jaishank said...

All those who feel Gandhi deserved it, I strongly recommend them to read 'My Experiments with Truth - Gandhiji's Autobiography' before commenting on the Father of the nation.
If you cant find one, let me know, I will be glad to send a copy.

Anonymous said...

M.K.Gandhi- Great man - Great mistake. There must be a foolstop like Godse made. This may be true or untrue the speech, but we should take it true. It doesn't matter wheher this is Godse's or mine but the facts and thoughts forwarded here is true. It was the The God Himself who wanted to kill M.K.Gandhi. Godse was only the hand to do this.

Anonymous said...

M.K.Gandhi- Great man - Great mistake. There must be a foolstop like Godse made. This may be true or untrue the speech, but we should take it true. It doesn't matter whether this is Godse's or mine, but the facts and thoughts forwarded here is true. It was the The God Himself who wanted to kill M.K.Gandhi. Godse was only the hand to do this.

Chandra Shekhar said...

I don't doubt that Gandhi was a person of great will power and he had power to attract illiterate and sentimental mass that time. However, I highly doubt if he was practical and if he has any idea of how the country can actually be made independent. The two most important factors that is believed to have brought the independence to India, are: 1.Weakened Britain as a result of WW2 and 2.Disobedience of Indian soldiers in British army and their sympathy towards Azad Hind Fauz. Mahatma Gandhi was just lucky to get the credit.

Anonymous said...

DESH BHAKTA VIR PUNDIT SRI NATHURAM GODSE WAS A TRUE PATRIOTIC TO THE NATION AND MAHATMA GANDHI WAS TRUE PATRIOTIC TO HUMANITY.DESH BHAKTA VIR PUNDIT SRI NATHURAM GODSE SHOULD BE RECOGNISED AND HONERED BOTH BY PEOPLE AND GOVERNMENT OF INDIA JUST AS THEY DO FOR MAHATMA GANDHI.

Anonymous said...

Yes exactly, in some moments I can bruit about that I acquiesce in with you, but you may be inasmuch as other options.
to the article there is quiet a definitely as you did in the decrease efflux of this request www.google.com/ie?as_q=antispyware professional 4.0.0.1126 ?
I noticed the utter you have not used. Or you partake of the dreary methods of helping of the resource. I suffer with a week and do necheg

Anonymous said...

The speech is entirely true. Especially the part 'Violent Pacifist'. Precisely why he was declined several times for the Nobel Peace Prize

Anonymous said...

HEY! I ALWAYS HATED GANDHI AND AFTER READING THE TRIAL OF GODSE I REALLY DETEST HIM,IF HE HAD STILL LIVED ON WE WOULD HAVE BEEN SLAVES OF MUSLIMS I IT IS NOT BECAUSE OF GANDHI WE HAVE GOT OUR INDEPENDENCE BRITISH WERE WEAK CAUSE OF WORLD WAR2 .I FEEL EVERY BODY SHOULD KNOW THE TRUTH AND THROW THE GANDHI PHOTOS AND STATUES AWAY AND REPLACE THEM BY,BHAGATSINGH ,RANA,SUBHAS CHANDRA BHOSE ,

Anonymous said...

I think we should understand Godse's thoughts. He already predicted what's going to happen after divinding our mother land and are witnessing this in our day to day lives today. I honestly feel our so called great leaders should never allow this to happen. why gandhi didn't go for fasting when the country was going to be divided? why he supported too much for dividing the country. why he didn't think about the future of the country & lives of people. He infulenced his mass crowed to agree his wishes which is thought less.

I think at present we need people like Godse to ensure that we dont loose our mother land.

jai hind ..

Anonymous said...

nathuram was great!!!!!!!!!!!

Vishnu Somasekhar said...

To the one who asked us to read "My experiments with truth" bu M.K. GANDHI ::> I don't know what is it in that book that you speak so highly of. I've read that and some other compilations from Mr. M.K. Gandhi. We, after reading that book or some other from him, tend to reach to a conclusion that what ever he did was true. But its always better to read or refer to a work by third party writers. And after reading some of such third party books, of which Freedom at midnight is noteworthy, I am no longer under the "charisma" of M.K Gandhi. So please analyse facts first before you give away free advice to people.

To that guy who think the speech is not real ::> Sir, I think you know about the fact that Godse used to manage a newspaper named 'Hindu Rashtra'. After knowing this fact, I think, one cannot be doubtful in his ability to use the right words.

Unknown said...

Well to all those Gandhi fans, I just want to ask one question, on whom were his experiments with truth on? why was it always on hindus? what was his problem with Hindus can nevr understand, his son dis owning him was probably the right thing, this man has left us as a nation of cowards and also a nation of roughes, in discplined people and have nots who care two hoots for the country, thanks Mr.Gandhi for converting this great country to a country it is today.

Unknown said...

Well to all those Gandhi fans, I just want to ask one question, on whom were his experiments with truth on? why was it always on hindus? what was his problem with Hindus can nevr understand, his son dis owning him was probably the right thing, this man has left us as a nation of cowards and also a nation of roughes, in discplined people and have nots who care two hoots for the country, thanks Mr.Gandhi for converting this great country to a country it is today.